Showing posts with label kingdom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label kingdom. Show all posts

When One Size Doesn't Fit All

What Dogs Taught Me About People, Church, and the Expectations We Place on One Another

For many years, dogs were an important part of my life. My wife and I operated a kennel, bred and showed dogs, and for a number of years I ran my own dog-training business. During that time, I learned a great deal about dogs. But looking back, I realize that dogs – and the people who lived with them – also taught me quite a bit about people.

One of the simplest lessons was this: dogs are not all the same.

That sounds obvious. A Labrador Retriever is not a Siberian Husky. A Border Collie is not a Scottish Terrier. Different breeds were developed for different purposes, and even within the same breed individual dogs differ in temperament, sensitivity, confidence, drive, ability, and the way they respond to the world around them.

That matters when you are trying to train one.

Suppose I wanted a dog to accompany me hunting and retrieve birds from icy water. I would hardly choose a breed developed to pull sleds and then become disappointed when it didn't perform as well as a Labrador Retriever. The sled dog might be intelligent, willing, strong, and exceptionally good at what it was bred to do. It might even learn to retrieve. But it isn't a Labrador.

If I forget that, eventually I may blame the dog for failing to become something it was never intended to be.

Over the years, I have begun to wonder whether we sometimes do something remarkably similar in the church.

There is Christianity, and then there is what I sometimes think of as churchianity — the habits, expectations, assumptions, and patterns that develop within church culture and can gradually become confused with Christianity itself. The distinction matters because sometimes what we expect from another Christian comes clearly from Christ. Sometimes it comes mostly from us.

Christian communities inevitably develop expectations about what a serious Christian should look like. Some of those expectations come directly from Scripture and should never be discarded simply because they are difficult. Christians really are called to love one another, forgive, serve, grow in holiness, care for those in need, remain faithful, bear witness to Christ, and put the interests of others ahead of themselves.

But other expectations can quietly attach themselves to those biblical commands.

We can develop a fairly standard picture of the committed Christian. Perhaps such a person is outgoing, comfortable praying aloud, eager to attend every group activity, able to speak easily about faith with strangers, emotionally expressive during worship, confident giving a testimony, and comfortable visiting people he hardly knows. Well – for some Christians, many of those things come naturally. For others, they don't.

The danger begins when we confuse a biblical expectation with one particular way of fulfilling it. The command may apply to every Christian without requiring every Christian to respond to it in exactly the same way.

And this is where something else I learned from dogs becomes useful.

Imagine that I own a large farm with hundreds of sheep and need dogs to help gather and move them. I would probably look for Border Collies or another breed developed for that purpose. I would not assemble a group of Scottish Terriers and then become angry because they wouldn't herd sheep like Border Collies.

The terriers might be excellent dogs. They might be intelligent, courageous, persistent, and exceptionally capable of doing what terriers were developed to do. But none of those qualities would make them Border Collies.

Suppose, however, that I didn't understand that. At first I might assume the problem was training. So I train harder. When that doesn't work, I increase the pressure. Then I might begin comparing my terriers with the Border Collies on the neighbouring farm. Look at them. Why can't you do that?

Eventually I may conclude that my dogs are stubborn. They simply won't do what I am asking.

But what if “won't” isn't the problem? What if they don't understand? What if my method is wrong? What if the task requires abilities they simply do not possess? What if they could accomplish part of what I am asking, but in a different way? And what happens if I keep increasing the pressure because I have mistaken inability for unwillingness? Worse yet, imagine the terrier himself could somehow come to believe that he really ought to be able to do what the Border Collie does.

At some point, I may damage the very animal I am trying to train.

I wonder how often something similar happens to Christians. They see another Christian doing easily what they themselves find extraordinarily difficult. Perhaps that person prays beautifully in public. Perhaps he can walk up to a complete stranger and begin talking about Jesus. Perhaps she thrives in groups and seems to know exactly what to say when someone is hurting.

And somewhere, explicitly or implicitly, comes the message: This is what a committed Christian must look like.

So the person tries harder. When that doesn't work, the thought may become: I must not be trying hard enough.

Later, perhaps discouragement and: There must be something wrong with my faith.

Eventually that might become: There must be something wrong with me.

But perhaps somewhere along the way a different question should have been asked: Was the expectation itself ever right?

That question does not mean there are no expectations in the Christian life. Quite the opposite. It asks us to distinguish between expectations that actually come from Christ and those we have created ourselves.

That distinction matters because Christianity is not merely about producing individual converts. Jesus did not simply tell His followers to go and get people saved. He told them to make disciples – to teach people to obey everything He had commanded.

That requires people. It requires relationships, teaching, correction, encouragement, patience, example, and time. And because one generation eventually gives way to another, what Christians learn must be passed on. The mission therefore involves more than reaching people. It involves forming people and communities capable of carrying the life and teaching of Christ forward.

We see something of this immediately after Pentecost. Thousands responded to the apostles' message, but Acts does not simply tell us that thousands of individuals were now saved. Those people began forming a community. They devoted themselves to the apostles' teaching, fellowship, breaking bread, and prayer. They ate together. They shared with those in need. They worshipped and learned together.

A community was taking shape. And communities require different kinds of people.

It is easy when reading Acts to concentrate on people like Paul, Peter, and Barnabas. They travelled. They preached. They established churches. Their stories dominate the book because Acts is telling us how the gospel spread.

But most Christians were not Paul.

Behind the prominent names were thousands of Christians whose names we will never know. They stayed home. They raised families, worked at trades, cared for one another, practised hospitality, supported those who travelled, cared for the poor, prayed, endured hardship, and lived out their allegiance to Christ in their own communities. They were part of the mission too.

That does not mean they had no responsibility to bear witness to their faith. The lives and words of ordinary Christians were themselves part of the church's witness. But the New Testament never suggests that every Christian was expected to become Paul.

The Great Commission belongs to the church, but that does not mean every member of the church performs the same function in carrying it out. Paul makes precisely this point when he describes the church as a body.

A body needs eyes, ears, hands, and feet. Paul asks what would happen if the whole body were an eye. How would it hear? If the whole body were an ear, how would it smell? His point is almost impossible to miss. The body works because its members are not all the same.

I think we sometimes reduce Paul's teaching about the body to a discussion about discovering our particular “spiritual gift.” There is nothing wrong with asking where our abilities might best be used. But Paul's point is larger than helping Christians discover their spiritual aptitude. He is teaching us how to understand one another.

The eye must not expect the hand to become another eye. The head cannot tell the feet that they are unnecessary. And one member should not conclude that because he cannot perform the function of another member, he therefore has little value to the body. Difference is not a defect in Paul's picture. It is necessary.

The fact that Paul found it necessary to say this suggests that the problem is hardly new. Some gifts were more visible than others. Some naturally attracted greater attention. Paul did not solve that problem by eliminating the differences. He placed them within something larger: they were different parts of one body, and the body needed them all. This becomes especially important when we ask what we believe the church is actually here to accomplish.

I have become convinced that something significant happens when personal salvation becomes almost the whole of what we mean by the gospel. Personal salvation is certainly part of the gospel – an indispensable part – but the gospel Jesus proclaimed was the gospel of the Kingdom.

When our understanding of the gospel narrows, the work of the church can begin to narrow with it. And when the work narrows, our picture of the kind of Christian who is most useful can narrow as well.

If the church's mission is understood mainly as getting unsaved people saved, then the activities most directly connected with that task naturally become the activities we value most.

Preaching becomes especially important. Evangelism becomes especially important. Missionary work becomes especially important. And Christians who can easily approach strangers, explain the gospel, preach publicly, or bring people into church can begin to look like the Christians who are doing what Christians are really supposed to do.

But what about everyone else?

If the mission is (as I believe) larger – if it involves making disciples and creating and nurturing communities of people learning to live under the lordship of Christ – then suddenly the picture becomes much larger too.

We need, so to speak, the butcher, the baker, and the candlestick maker.

We need teachers and encouragers, organizers and helpers. We need people who practise hospitality and people who quietly notice someone in need. We need those who care for children, those who sit with the lonely, those who provide financially, those who repair what is broken, those who study carefully, those who exercise wisdom, those who pray faithfully, and those who simply become dependable friends.

We need people capable of standing before hundreds. But we also need people capable of sitting quietly beside one.

Not everyone will be equally good at all these things. Nor, I would suggest, were they intended to be.

None of this excuses us from following Christ. Personality is not an excuse for selfishness. Temperament does not remove the command to love our neighbour. Fear does not mean we never have to grow. A Scottish Terrier can learn things that do not come naturally to a Scottish Terrier.

But growth is not the same thing as becoming someone else. Perhaps that is one of the things the church needs to become better at recognizing. When someone continually struggles to meet an expectation, before deciding that the problem is unwillingness, perhaps we should ask some questions.

  • Does this person understand what is being asked?
  • Is the expectation actually biblical?
  • Are we confusing faithfulness with one particular personality or ability?
  • Could this person fulfil the same Christian responsibility in a different way?
  • And what happens if we simply keep increasing the pressure?

Those questions do not remove legitimate expectations. They force us to examine them.

Because if the church really is a body, then we should expect its members to be different. We should not merely tolerate those differences. We should recognise that some of them are necessary for the body to become what it was intended to be.

A community requires a remarkable variety of people. A narrowly defined task requires a much narrower range of abilities. And if our picture of Christian mission becomes too narrow, our picture of the “useful Christian” can narrow along with it.

Before long, we may find ourselves asking the Scottish Terrier why he isn't herding sheep.


The Forgotten Language of Representation

Among the greatest barriers modern Christians face in understanding Scripture is not simply a lack of knowledge about ancient geography, history, or culture. Nor is it usually a question of intelligence or sincerity. More often, it is one of perspective.

Modern readers instinctively approach the Bible as individuals. We ask what a passage means to me, what God promises me, and how it applies to my personal faith. Those are not illegitimate questions. The Bible certainly speaks to individuals. Yet they are not always the questions the biblical writers themselves were primarily addressing.

The world of Scripture was profoundly communal. People understood themselves not first as isolated individuals, but as members of families, tribes, nations, and covenants. Identity was rooted in belonging. Individuals lived within a people, and that people was often represented by one who acted on its behalf.

Because we read from a different cultural perspective, we frequently hear individual promises where Scripture is addressing a community, private commands where it is forming a people, and personal experiences where it is describing God's work among an entire covenant family. Without realizing it, we often replace the Bible's corporate framework with our own individualistic assumptions.

Modern Western culture reinforces this tendency. It teaches us to value personal freedom, personal choice, personal rights, and personal responsibility. We naturally ask, What does this mean for me? When we open the Bible, we instinctively read its promises, warnings, commands, and stories through that same lens.

Yet while Scripture never ignores the individual, it rarely begins there. More often, it tells the story of God forming a people, establishing His kingdom, and working through representative men and women whose actions affect those they represent. Until we recognize that difference, we will often misunderstand not only individual passages but the larger story the Bible is telling.

To be clear, the Bible certainly recognizes the importance of the individual. Each person is called to repentance, faith, and obedience. Each will one day stand before God. Yet the biblical writers rarely present individuals as isolated, self-defining people.

I would now like to consider a question that has puzzled many Christians. Eve ate first, yet throughout the rest of Scripture the fall is consistently attributed to Adam. Paul never says that sin entered the world through Adam and Eve. Instead, he writes, "Through one man sin entered the world." Why?

Here are a few more questions to give some thought to:

-         Why is Noah remembered as saving his household?

-         Why is Abraham treated as the father of a nation?

-         Why does David's census bring judgment on Israel?

-         Why does one high priest make atonement for the nation?

-         Why can Isaiah's Servant stand for many?

-         Why does Paul compare Christ only with Adam?

These are not isolated examples. They reveal a way of thinking that is woven throughout Scripture but is often unfamiliar to modern readers. The Bible repeatedly tells its story through representatives.

This difference is easy to overlook because it is so foreign to our way of thinking. Yet once it is seen, it appears everywhere. Adam represents humanity. Abraham represents his descendants. Israel is represented by its priests and kings. David stands for his kingdom. The Servant represents faithful Israel. Finally, Christ comes not merely as another individual among many but as the representative head of a new humanity.

Perhaps nowhere is the contrast between these two ways of thinking more significant than in the doctrine of salvation. We often speak of Jesus dying for me, obeying for me, rising for me. Those statements are true. But they are not where Scripture itself begins. The New Testament first presents Christ as the One who fulfilled humanity's calling, succeeding where Adam failed. Through faith, men and women are united to Him and therefore share in all that He accomplished on behalf of His people.

It is the thesis of this study that the Bible is not primarily the story of how God saves isolated individuals. Rather, it is the story of how God restores humanity and, ultimately, all of His creation. Individual salvation is an essential part of that story, but it is not the story itself. The larger biblical narrative is one of creation, covenant, kingdom, new creation, and the formation of a redeemed humanity under Jesus Christ—its representative King.

The story begins not with sin but with creation. Before there was a problem to solve, there was a purpose to fulfill.

When God created mankind, He created Adam as His image-bearer and entrusted him with a remarkable commission. He was to exercise dominion over the earth, cultivate it, fill it with God's image-bearers, and govern it under God's authority. Eve was then created to stand alongside him as a suitable helper, sharing in that same calling. Together they were to extend the order, fruitfulness, and blessing of Eden throughout the whole earth.

Genesis 2 shows that Adam received this commission directly from God. He was given both extraordinary privilege and clear responsibility. He lived in God's presence, walked with his Creator, and knew both the task entrusted to him and the single boundary that God had established.

The tragedy of Eden, therefore, is far greater than a poor personal choice or the acceptance of bad advice. Humanity's first image-bearer failed in the vocation for which he had been created. The one entrusted with representing God's rule within creation rebelled against the very God whose image he bore. The consequences reached far beyond Adam himself. His failure affected not only his own life but the destiny of humanity and, indeed, the whole created order.

 

From this point forward, the biblical story is no longer simply about two individuals in a garden. It becomes the story of God's determination to accomplish through a faithful representative what humanity's first representative failed to do.

As we continue reading Scripture, it becomes increasingly clear that Adam is not an isolated case. Rather, he is the first in a pattern that appears repeatedly throughout the biblical story. Again and again, God works through representative individuals whose actions affect the people they represent.

After the flood, Noah becomes the head of a renewed humanity. Through Abraham, God establishes the covenant family through whom all the nations of the earth will be blessed. Moses stands before God on behalf of Israel, while Aaron and the high priest represent the nation in its worship and atonement. David represents the kingdom, and the faithfulness—or unfaithfulness—of Israel's kings repeatedly shapes the destiny of the people they govern. Even Isaiah's Servant is presented as one who stands for others, accomplishing on their behalf what they could not accomplish for themselves.

These examples are not unrelated stories. Together they reveal a consistent pattern. Throughout Scripture, God repeatedly chooses to work through representatives. The actions of one often carry consequences for the many.

By the time we reach the New Testament, this pattern is firmly established. The idea of one person acting on behalf of God's people should no longer seem unusual. What is surprising is that Jesus is presented not merely as another representative in the succession of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Aaron, David, and the Servant, but as the One in whom every previous representative finds his fulfillment.

Jesus succeeds where Adam failed. He embodies the faithfulness that Israel so often lacked. He is both the true High Priest and the perfect sacrifice. He is the promised Son of David who reigns forever, and He is the Servant who bears the sins of many. Every representative role in Scripture ultimately points beyond itself to Him.

In fulfilling every representative role, Jesus fulfilled humanity’s calling. As He did so, He bore the curse brought upon humanity by our first representative and He defeated humanity’s enemy. Jesus inaugurated a new humanity

At this point an obvious question presents itself. If the representative pattern is woven so deeply into the fabric of Scripture, why is it so rarely recognized today? Why do many sincere Christians instinctively think first of "my salvation," "my relationship with Jesus," and "my eternal destiny," while the biblical writers so often speak of a people, a kingdom, a covenant, a body, and a new humanity?

Part of the answer lies not in the Bible itself but in the culture from which most modern readers approach it. We live in societies that prize the individual above almost everything else. Personal rights, personal fulfillment, personal choice, and personal achievement are celebrated as defining virtues. Much of this has contributed positively to society. The dignity of the individual, personal responsibility, and liberty of conscience are values that deserve to be preserved.

Yet every culture also teaches us how to see the world. Without realizing it, we often carry those assumptions with us when we read Scripture. We instinctively ask, What does this passage mean to me? How does this affect my personal relationship with God? What promises does God make to me? These are important questions, but they are not always the questions the biblical story asks first.

From its opening pages, Scripture places its emphasis not on isolated individuals but on humanity in relationship. God's first recorded words concerning mankind are not speaking of an autonomous individual seeking personal fulfillment but of humanity as His image-bearers. "Let us make mankind in our image, after our likeness." Immediately the narrative speaks of "male and female," of being fruitful, multiplying, filling the earth, and exercising dominion over creation. Humanity is given a shared vocation before it is given a personal story.

Even the first problem identified in God's good creation is striking. Before sin enters the world, before guilt, death, or judgment appear, God declares, "It is not good that the man should be alone." While these words certainly prepare for the institution of marriage, they also reveal something fundamental about human nature itself. Humanity was never intended to exist in isolation. Men and women were created for fellowship with God, with one another, and with the shared responsibility of bearing God's image throughout the earth.

Notice the order in which Genesis unfolds. The first command is not, "Save your soul," but "Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it." The first concern is not individual guilt but humanity's calling. The first institution is not government but family. The first commission is not private spirituality but the shared task of extending God's righteous rule throughout His creation.

This communal emphasis continues throughout the rest of Scripture. God calls Abraham not merely to bless one man but to establish a people through whom all nations will be blessed. Israel is redeemed not as a collection of unrelated individuals but as a covenant nation. Jesus gathers disciples into a community, not merely converts into separate spiritual lives. At Pentecost the Holy Spirit forms a church, and the New Testament repeatedly describes believers as a body, a household, a temple, a priesthood, and a holy nation. The Bible begins with humanity in a garden and ends with redeemed humanity living together in a city where God dwells among His people.

Perhaps this explains why the New Testament so often speaks in ways that seem unfamiliar to modern ears. We frequently begin with the deeply personal question, "How can I be saved?" Scripture certainly answers that question, but it places it within a much larger story. From beginning to end, the Bible invites us to ask, "What kind of humanity is God creating?" Individual salvation is not diminished by that question; rather, it finds its proper place within God's larger purpose of restoring humanity—and ultimately all creation—under the reign of His Son.

This perspective sheds fresh light on Paul's argument in Romans 5. When explaining the origin of sin and the work of Christ, Paul does not focus first on isolated individuals making isolated decisions. Instead, he sets before us two representative heads and two humanities. "Through one man sin entered the world, and death through sin" (Romans 5:12). Just as Adam's disobedience affected those he represented, so Christ's obedience brings life to those who are united to Him. Paul's concern is not merely how individual sinners receive forgiveness, but how God is replacing the old humanity in Adam with a new humanity in Christ. Salvation, therefore, is far more than God's rescue of isolated people. It is His work of creating a redeemed humanity under a faithful Representative—the very purpose toward which the biblical story has been moving since Eden. 

When Interpretations Shape the Church: Part II - How Inherited Beliefs Influence Christian Teaching, Practice, and Mission

This is the second of a two part essay. Part 1 can be found at:  When Interpretation Becomes Authority: Part 1 - How Human Assumptions Shape...